How to know when to build custom software

We usually tell clients when they don't need custom software. This month we built our own tool to manage leave and shifts, and here's how we knew it was worth it.

We always look closely at whether a client really needs custom software, and we're not afraid to tell them when they don't. Often, a well-chosen off-the-shelf tool is the right answer. This month we took our own advice the other way, and built it ourselves.

Like most small businesses, we run on more tools than we'd like. One of them handled annual leave and shifts. I won't name it, but it plugs neatly into a very popular chat app made by a very large software company. You can probably guess.

Recently it hit a bug that caused us real headaches. The details are HR business, so I'll leave them there. What stuck with me more was the feeling that nobody has looked after this tool for years. One of the supposed benefits of buying from a tech giant is that someone, somewhere, is keeping the thing alive. Apparently not.

So we asked the question we'd ask any client: is it worth fixing around this, or is it time to own it?

Moving it into awesome. time

We already had a home for it.

awesome. time is our own tool for tracking work, built so retainer clients can see exactly what we've done for them. Leave and shifts are about people's time too, so it felt like they'd always belonged there.

I've spent this week testing it for real. Checking in, logging time, managing tasks and booking leave, all in one place. After years of hopping between apps, it's a genuine relief.

We've also made sure it's nice to use. Internal tools usually get the leftover design effort. This one gets used every day by everyone, so it deserves better than that.

When building your own makes sense

I'm not saying everyone should reinvent the wheel. But when the fit is right, custom software doesn't just save a few quid, it makes your working day noticeably better. This one ticked every box we look for with a client:

  1. You already own most of it. We had awesome. time, this was an extension, not a new product.

  2. You're paying for several tools that each do one job. Fold them into one and the costs, logins and duplicated data go with them.

  3. The off-the-shelf option has stopped improving. If the vendor isn't investing in it, you're paying for something that's standing still.

  4. You use it every day. Daily friction adds up fast across a whole team. That's where a better fit pays back quickest.

If your business ticks most of those, it's worth a conversation. If it ticks one, buy the off-the-shelf tool and get on with your day.

What's next

We're rolling it out to the whole team over the coming weeks, and then it becomes part of what clients get in awesome. time too.

And if you've got a tool you're paying for that's quietly let you down, we're happy to talk it through. Even if the answer is "keep it".

Chris Key Takeaway

When the fit is right, custom software doesn't just save a few quid, it makes your working day noticeably better.

Let's talk software Get Started